2006 Ombudsman Recommendations

Recommendation:

Revise policy to clearly articulate the custodial responsibility of prisoners who are undergoing polygraph examinations.

BPD Response:  Adopted

Recommendation:

Consider adopting a policy or written procedures concerning guarding prisoners who are in unsecured locations.

BPD Response:  Adopted

Recommendation:

Clarify policy to clearly communicate a standard of care for all injured or ill persons encountered by BPD employees, regardless of the causation, and that adequate equipment and training should be provided.

BPD Response:  Adopted

Recommendation:

Review policy concerning the release of confidential information: 1) State a clear and usable definition;  (Previously recommended in 2001)  2) Examine the apparent practice of affording special rights not found in the law to parents of those who have reached the age of 18.

BPD Response:  Pending

Recommendation:

Evaluate current training to determine its effectiveness in preparing officers to continuously assess and evaluate the effectiveness of his or her fire when discharging a firearm.

BPD Response:  Not Adopted

Recommendation:

Adopt BPD and APD policy language that: 1) Clearly articulates that shooting at a moving vehicle, its driver, and/or its passengers is inherently dangerous and generally ineffective;  2) Reminds officers of their public responsibility to avoid tactics that unnecessarily create dangerous circumstances or the need to use deadly force if other equally effective options are available; 3) Informs officers that moving out of the way of an on-coming vehicle, retreating, reposition, and obtaining cover are sound police tactics, not examples of cowardice or weakness;  4) Requires officers to take into account the presence of other vehicles, pedestrians, innocent bystanders, and occupied structures and weigh the potential danger to others before shooting at a moving vehicle, its driver, or any ccupants;  5) Prohibits officers from intentionally placing themselves in front of or behind a stationary occupied vehicle;  6) Prohibits officers from intentionally stepping in the path of a moving vehicle;  7) Directs officers to avoid placing themselves in an inherently dangerous position which would expose them to danger should the suspect vehicle become mobile;  8) Requires officers to get out of the path of a moving vehicle if at all physically possible;  9) Prohibits officers from firing their weapons at a moving vehicle, its driver, and/or its passengers except as a last resort when: a) the officer is physically unable to either get out of the vehicle's path and/or, b) a deadly threat is present, other than the approach of the vehicle itself (e.g., shots are being fired at the officer or others from inside the vehicle) and the officer and/or those being threatened are able to obtain sufficient cover.

BPD Response:  Adopted (in part)

Recommendation:

Develop and implement education and training sufficient to implement the policy recommended above.

BPD Response:  Adopted

Recommendation:

The ombudsman repeats and reinforces his 2005 recommendation that BPD make such changes to current audio recording and critical incident policies and procedures as are necessary to require officers to audio record all statements made by involved parties, victims, suspects, witnesses, etc. officers and non-officers alike.

BPD Response: Not Adopted

Recommendation:

Closely scrutinize the practice of searching a dead suspect's home, especially in cases where the suspect was killed by law enforcement officers.  (Police policy and procedures must make it clear that the deliberate use of a Fourth Amendment warrant for purpose of gathering evidence for the defense of a civil action must not take place.)

BPD Response:  Not Adopted

Recommendation:

Work with CITF to institute those changes to CITF procedures and management oversight necessary to insure the proper identification, collection, handling, testing, and safeguarding of evidence in the course of a CITF investigation.

BPD Response:  Adopted

Recommendation:

Immediately begin a formal program of training and establishing Crisis Intervention Teams.

BPD Response:  Adopted

Recommendation:

Design and implement on-going training for all officers to improve their ability to effectively accomplish the difficult responsibilities of being a primary officer for incidents that include an existing or potential threat to life or property and require the response of two or more officers.

BPD Response:  Adopted